The short answer
There is no single best tool. The right choice depends on what you need to archive.
- Only your official social media accounts, across many departments: Brolly or CivicPlus Social Media Archiving.
- Social media and your website together: Pagefreezer.
- Social media as one channel among email, text and voice: Smarsh or Global Relay.
- A financial services firm, not a government agency: Smarsh, Global Relay or Red Oak.
Keep in mind: Brolly prepared this comparison, so read it as one vendor's view. Every description of another product comes from that vendor's own website, reviewed November 20, 2026, and the pages are listed under Sources. Test any claim, including ours, with your own accounts before you buy.
What a government archive has to do
- Capture continuously, so content is kept before it can be edited or deleted.
- Keep the whole conversation: posts, public comments, replies and media, attached to each other.
- Keep edits as versions and deletions as records, with times.
- Keep metadata and evidence that supports integrity review.
- Search across every account at once and export in formats a requester and a reviewer can use.
- Let you control retention under your own schedule.
Use those six as your scoring sheet. The buyer's guide turns them into questions for vendors.
Six tools at a glance
| Vendor | Published focus | Beyond social media | Published pricing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brolly | Social media archiving for government and regulated organizations | Monitoring alerts on connected channels are included. Insights and Protect are optional. No website or email archiving | Yes. Plans by new records captured each month |
| CivicPlus Social Media Archiving (formerly ArchiveSocial) | Social media archiving for government agencies, educational institutions and law enforcement | Sold within the wider CivicPlus government technology portfolio | No. Pricing on request |
| Pagefreezer | Cloud archiving for federal, state and local agencies and regulated organizations | Website archiving and other digital archiving products | No. Plans are quoted individually |
| Smarsh | Digital communications compliance across many channels | Email, mobile, voice, web and collaboration tools | No. Contact sales |
| Global Relay | Communications archiving, supervision and eDiscovery | Email, voice, text, instant messaging and website archive | Not found on vendor site |
| Red Oak (formerly MirrorWeb) | Advertising review, supervision and archiving for regulated firms | Email, mobile and text, workplace chat and website archiving | No. Book a demo |
Published capabilities are vendor descriptions, not results of an independent product test.
Vendor by vendor
Brolly
Consider it when you need to connect official accounts across many departments and give records, communications and legal staff access, with a published price.
Brolly's scope is social media archiving. It captures supported posts, public comments, replies, edits and deletions from connected accounts on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, X, YouTube, LinkedIn and TikTok in near real time, with direct messages where the platform API provides them. Teams search across connected accounts and export PDF, CSV, HTML or JSON with digital checksums. Plans are sized by new records captured each month, with unlimited accounts, users and storage, and start with a 30-day free trial. Brolly is ISO/IEC 27001:2022 certified and CSA STAR registered, with controls aligned to NIST SP 800-53.
Limits to know: Brolly does not provide website or email archiving and does not currently import third-party archives. See pricing, security and the product facts.
CivicPlus Social Media Archiving (formerly ArchiveSocial)
Consider it when public self-service access is a requirement, or your agency already buys other CivicPlus products.
CivicPlus describes the product as built for government agencies, educational institutions and law enforcement, and advertises a public access option called Open Archive. Pricing is on request. Ask for a coverage matrix for your exact platforms and content types, the scope and price of public access, and your export and exit terms. See Brolly vs ArchiveSocial / CivicPlus.
Pagefreezer
Consider it when you need website archiving and social media archiving from one supplier.
Pagefreezer describes itself as a cloud-based archiving platform serving federal, state and local agencies. It offers social media archiving alongside website and other digital archiving products, and its government page describes a self-service public portal. Plans are quoted individually. Confirm which products are in your quote. See Brolly vs Pagefreezer.
Smarsh
Consider it when social media is one of many channels your organization must archive together.
Smarsh describes its business as digital communications compliance and names financial services, the public sector, energy and utilities, and life sciences as its industries. It lists email, mobile, voice, web and collaboration channels beside social media, and says its social capture supports legal hold and eDiscovery. Pricing is not published. Ask how public comments on an agency page are captured and kept with their posts, and for a social-media-only quote.
Global Relay
Consider it when you need supervision and eDiscovery across all communications.
Global Relay describes itself as a provider of electronic communications archiving, messaging, supervision and eDiscovery, and lists government among its industries. It offers legal hold within its eDiscovery product. We did not find pricing or a confirmed list of social media connectors on its site. Ask for both.
Red Oak (formerly MirrorWeb)
Consider it when you are a financial services firm.
Red Oak's website states that MirrorWeb combined with Red Oak in 2026 and that its archiving product is now Red Oak Archiving. It describes its customers as regulated firms. We did not find a government or public sector offering on the pages we reviewed. Pricing is not published.
Side by side for government buyers
| Vendor | Positioned mainly for government | Website archiving offered | Public access option | Prices published |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brolly | Yes, with regulated industries | No | No | Yes |
| CivicPlus | Yes | Not found on vendor site | Yes | No |
| Pagefreezer | Yes, with regulated industries | Yes | Yes | No |
| Smarsh | Public sector is one of four industries listed | Yes | Not found on vendor site | No |
| Global Relay | Government is one of seven industries listed | Yes | Not found on vendor site | Not found on vendor site |
| Red Oak | Not found on vendor site | Yes | Not found on vendor site | No |
“Not found on vendor site” means we could not find it stated on the vendor's own website on November 20, 2026. It does not mean the feature is absent. Ask the vendor, and ask every vendor for a written coverage matrix for your exact platforms, account types, comments, messages and historical date ranges.
How to choose
- Write down what you need to archive. Social media only, or websites, email and text as well. This decides half the shortlist.
- List every account and platform. Ask each vendor for written coverage of that exact list.
- Decide whether the public needs to search the archive. If so, shortlist vendors that publish a public access option.
- Get quotes on the same scope. Same accounts, same users, same term. Add a busy month and ask what changes. The cost guide explains the pricing units.
- Run the same test with each vendor. Post, comment, edit and delete on a test account, then search for it and export it. Use the evaluation guide.
- Have IT review the security evidence and have your records officer sign off.
Sources and scope
This is Brolly's comparison for buyers, based on public product information reviewed November 20, 2026. It is not an independent benchmark or a promise of future product behavior. Vendor descriptions are the vendors' own and can change.
- CivicPlus Social Media Archiving: product page and ArchiveSocial naming
- Pagefreezer social media archiving and Pagefreezer for government
- Smarsh social channels and Smarsh for government
- Global Relay for government and Global Relay eDiscovery and legal hold
- Red Oak: MirrorWeb announcement and Red Oak channels
- Brolly pricing, Brolly security and Brolly product facts
Vendor names and trademarks belong to their respective owners. No affiliation is implied.
Common questions
What is the best social media archiving software for government?
It depends on scope. For social media alone, Brolly and CivicPlus Social Media Archiving are positioned for government. Pagefreezer adds website archiving. Smarsh and Global Relay address many communication channels. Test the shortlist against your own accounts before deciding.
Which social media archiving tools publish their prices?
Of the six vendors compared here, Brolly publishes its plans and prices. For the others we found a quote request, or could not find pricing on the vendor’s own site, when we reviewed them on November 20, 2026.
Which tool is best for public records requests?
The one that captured the content before it changed, lets you search every account at once, and exports the conversation with its dates and available metadata. Run a mock request with each shortlisted vendor.
Do these tools capture deleted comments?
Only content that was captured before it was deleted can be kept. Ask each vendor how soon after posting an item is captured, and test it with a harmless comment on a test account.
Is ArchiveSocial the same as CivicPlus?
CivicPlus describes its Social Media Archiving product as formerly ArchiveSocial. Treat the two names as the same product lineage when building a shortlist.
What happened to MirrorWeb?
Red Oak’s website states that MirrorWeb combined with Red Oak in 2026 and that its archiving product is now Red Oak Archiving.
Put the guide to work
Use the downloadable workbook to run the same capture, search and export test with every shortlisted vendor and record what you observe.